Tool Bag Vs. Bucket Vs. Tool Roll:  Here’s the Better Option…

Keeping your tools organized and handy is a priority, so whether you choose a tool bag, tool bucket, or tool roll, here’s the better option. Your tools are essential to daily work tasks, so you need them to be secure and last a long time.

Tool Bag vs. Bucket vs. Tool Roll:  Here's the Better Option...

Of the Tool Bag vs. Bucket vs. Tool Roll: Here’s the Better Option.

Tool Bags

One of the main advantages of choosing a tool bag for your tools is its portability. Tool bags often have wheels on the bottom like suitcases to allow you to pull them from place to place. The padded shoulder straps and hand grips allow balanced transport when carrying a tool bag.

Tool bags have much to recommend them. When you need a tool bag to carry what you require to work on a project, there are some qualities to consider.

  • The amount of storage you need
  • Whether you need several large pockets or if small pockets are better for holding nails, screws, and small tools
  • Storage pockets on the outside of the bag to hold the tools you use most often
  • Heavy-duty fabric to withstand the weight of the tools and constant use
  • Secure stitching and rugged zippers
  • A metal frame to keep the bag upright

Tool Bag Options

When you decide a heavy-duty tool bag is what you want to carry your tools from place to place, here are some of the best selections.

The Carhartt Legacy Tool Bag 14-Inch

The Carhartt Legacy Tool Bag 14-Inch is made of durable polyester handles and 1200 denier canvas. The exterior is waterproof to protect your tools from moisture damage.

$69.99
1 new from $69.99
Free shipping
Amazon Amazon.com
Last update was on: June 17, 2024 1:27 am

9.1Expert Score
Our Review of The Carhartt Legacy Tool Bag 14-Inch

We rated the Carhartt Legacy Tool Bag 14-Inch in a number of categories, including ease of use, features, value, quality, and customer satisfaction. Here are the results:

Ease of Use
9
Features
9
Value
9
Quality
9
Criteria name
10
Customer Satisfaction
9.5
Pros of the Carhartt Legacy Tool Bag 14-Inch, Carhartt Brown
  • The Carhartt bag comes in 14 and 16 inches, and 14 and 16 inches with a molded base
  • It has an interior metal frame to keep it upright
  • This bag has 23 exterior pockets
  • Can fit all your tools

DEWALT DGL573 Lighted Technician’s Tool Bag

The DeWalt name itself can recommend this DEWALT DGL573 Lighted Technician’s Tool Bag. It has 41 pockets to hold all your tools and attachments, with a special slot on the outside to hold a tape measure for easy access.

$84.95
4 new from $84.95
1 used from $72.00
Free shipping
Amazon Amazon.com
Last update was on: June 17, 2024 1:27 am

Pros of the DEWALT DGL573 Lighted Technician’s Tool Bag

  • An LED light on top of the bag can illuminate the interior and swivel to serve as a work light
  • The front flap stays open
  • Padded grip straps for less carrying discomfort
  • This is a sturdy bucket bag

Cons of the DEWALT DGL573 Lighted Technician’s Tool Bag

  • The light quits working and can’t be replaced

Tool Buckets

Tool buckets are a popular way to store all the tools you need for a job. This organizer fits around a five-gallon bucket so that you can carry the whole setup by the bucket handle. If you prefer a tool bucket to manage your tools, here are some great choices.

Bucket Boss 10056 Bucket Boss 5 Gallon Bucket Canvas Tool Holder and Organizer

The Bucket Boss 10056 Bucket Boss 5 Gallon Bucket Canvas Tool Holder and Organizer is durable canvas with double stitching. It fits a five-gallon bucket perfectly to hold any tool you need without digging around.

$42.65 $49.99
3 new from $42.65
1 used from $39.98
Free shipping
Amazon Amazon.com
Last update was on: June 17, 2024 1:27 am

Pros of the Bucket Boss 10056 Bucket Boss 5 Gallon Bucket Canvas Tool Holder and Organizer

  • There are 40 inner and 18 outer pockets
  • Three interior loops for hammers and drills
  • Additional space in the middle of the bucket for specialized tools

Cons of the Bucket Boss 10056 Bucket Boss 5 Gallon Bucket Canvas Tool Holder and Organizer

  • The inner pockets are too floppy
  • The elastic for the drill is unnecessary

CLC Custom Leathercraft 1119 Bucket Caddy Organizer

The CLC Custom Leathercraft 1119 Bucket Caddy Organizer boasts 13 double-row pockets inside and 34 triple-row outside. The design fits most five-gallon buckets. Here are the best features of this bucket caddy.

$22.94
35 new from $19.90
Free shipping
Amazon Amazon.com
Last update was on: June 17, 2024 1:27 am

Pros of the CLC Custom Leathercraft 1119 Bucket Caddy Organizer

  • Made of durable Cordura fabric
  • It is lightweight and strong
  • Great cost-effective solution for carrying tools

Cons of the CLC Custom Leathercraft 1119 Bucket Caddy Organizer

  • The pockets on the upper row are tight and make retrieving screws difficult

Tool Rolls

A handy tool roll is helpful to keep the tools organized, particularly when you don’t have enough space to store them separately. The tool roll is easy to roll up and carry with you on a job.

A tool roll is ideal for carrying into small work spaces. It keeps your tools from banging together and holds them securely until you need them. Some tool roll bags have a large compartment to hold the tools you need together, while the rest are stored away in other compartments.

Terrev Tool Roll Up Bag

The Terrev Tool Roll Up Bag has a carrying load of 150 pounds. The roll-up design makes it easy to carry over the shoulder with the shoulder strap.

$38.99
3 new from $29.99
Free shipping
Amazon Amazon.com
Last update was on: June 17, 2024 1:27 am

Pros of the Terrev Tool Roll Up Bag

  • 17 pockets with customizable labels
  • Detachable shoulder pad for easy carrying
  • A large capacity zippered pocket for flashlight, drill, etc.

Cons of the Terrev Tool Roll Up Bag

  • Won’t roll tightly when full of tools

Rhino USA Tool Bag Roll

This heavy-duty Rhino USA Tool Bag Roll canvas tool roll organizer has removable pouches. Rhino has a lifetime warranty if your tool roll rips, frays, or tears.

$46.90
4 new from $46.90
Free shipping
Amazon Amazon.com
Last update was on: June 17, 2024 1:27 am

Pros of the Rhino USA Tool Bag Roll

  • Metal zippers and clips
  • Labeled pouches for all your tools
  • Velcro pouches to remove and carry without taking the whole tool roll
  • Water resistant

Cons of the Rhino USA Tool Bag Roll

  • Needs a sturdier shoulder strap

Related Questions:

What is a Pocket Bucket?

A pocket bucket fits inside a standard 5 or 3 ½ gallon bucket. Use the inside of the bucket for specialty tools, and the outside has pockets and slots to hold your everyday tools. You can carry the bucket by the handle into a job and have all your tools within easy reach.

Is a Veto Pro Pac Worth the Hype?

A Veto Pro Pac has a loyal following due to their designs targeted to each trade. It has exceptional organization and space to spare. Its innovative tool backpack is the first backpack tool holder style available. Here are some of the benefits of a Veto Pro Pac tool holder.

  • It has a patented center panel for stabilization
  • A molded base, so the Pac stands upright
  • 46 pockets inside and outside
  • A quick-release handle to access the inner compartment quickly
  • Has D-rings, memory stick pockets, and a small pocket for a tablet

What Details Should You Look For in a Tool Bucket Holder?

One of the best ways to choose a tool bucket holder is the lay out your tools. Group each type so you can see how many pockets and slots you need. You should also decide whether you need zippered compartments to hold screws and other small items. Another factor to consider is whether you want the compartments to have built-in labels to indicate where everything belongs.

What are the Advantages of a Tool Roll Bag?

A tool roll bag is lighter than a tool bag or tool bucket organizer. However, this tool storage method doesn’t offer as much storage as the tool bag or tool bucket. The tool roll bag is portable and perfect for smaller jobs when you don’t need as many tools. It offers more protection for small tools than a tool bag or bucket.

What is the Most Durable Tool Holder?

The most durable tool holder is a toolbox. However, most toolboxes are not portable enough to carry your tools onto a job site. This is why tool bags, tool buckets, and tool rolls offer more mobility for your work needs.

Should I Get a White Tool Bag?

Some tradespeople like a white tool bag because it stands out from the rest of the construction. They also say that when you open a white tool bag, there is no more dark hole to search around for the tool you need. Some white tool bags have a clamshell opening that remains open until you shut and zip it at the end of the day.

Tool Belt Titans
Logo